Codependence vs. Interdependence vs. Independence: Which is the middle ground?

Relationships are an integral part of our lives, and we all want them to be healthy and fulfilling. However, sometimes we find ourselves in relationships that are more harmful than helpful. 

This is where the concepts of codependence, interdependence, and independence come in. 

So, let’s unpack the differences.

Codependence

Codependence is when you prioritize another person’s needs and wants over your own, to the extent that you neglect your own well-being. It often results in an unhealthy power dynamic in the relationship, where one person is the caretaker and the other is the dependent.

The negative impact of on relationships

Let’s start with an example;

Let’s say your partner has a drinking problem, and you feel like it’s your responsibility to make sure they don’t drink too much. You might avoid social events where alcohol is served, hide or throw away their alcohol, or make excuses for their behavior. 

In this situation, you are not only neglecting your own needs and wants, but you are also enabling their destructive behavior.

The negative impact of codependence on relationships is significant. It can lead to resentment, feelings of being trapped, and a loss of self-identity. Over time, it can also contribute to anxiety, depression, and other mental health issues.

How to recognize if you are codependent

Recognizing if you are this type can be tricky, but there are some common signs to look out for. Do you have trouble saying no to others? Do you find yourself putting others’ needs ahead of your own, even when it’s detrimental to your well-being? Do you feel like your own happiness is dependent on someone else’s actions or feelings? If you answered yes to any of these questions, you might be exhibiting codependent behavior.

Fortunately, this can be overcome. It takes time and effort, but the first step is recognizing that there is a problem. Setting boundaries and learning to prioritize your own needs and wants is crucial. Remember, you are not responsible for someone else’s behavior or emotions. You can support them, but you cannot control them. Seeking the help of a therapist or counselor can also be beneficial in overcoming this.

Interdependence

This term is often misunderstood as a lack of independence or as another form of codependence. However, it is an important and healthy aspect of any relationship. Interdependence is the ability to count on others for support while maintaining your own autonomy and sense of self. It involves mutual trust, emotional intimacy, respect, and communication. The ”independence” part in this style means your self-worth is secure and is not attached to your relationship. 

Examples of interdependent behavior

Examples of this behavior include making joint decisions, compromising, and supporting each other’s goals and interests. For example, you and your partner may have different career aspirations, but you can still support each other in pursuing those goals. You can offer each other advice and encouragement while maintaining your own sense of identity and independence.

The positive impact on relationships

The positive impact of this style on relationships is significant. It leads to a more equal and balanced power dynamic, which promotes mutual respect and understanding. It also fosters a sense of teamwork and collaboration, which can make overcoming challenges and achieving shared goals more rewarding.

How to recognize if you are interdependent

Recognizing if you are this type can be challenging because its a bit of grey area. Some signs of healthy connection include feeling comfortable leaning on others for support and being able to provide support without feeling overwhelmed or resentful. It’s important to remember that interdependence doesn’t mean sacrificing your own needs or desires for someone else.

Developing interdependence

Developing this way of relating takes effort and communication. It involves setting boundaries, being clear about your needs and expectations, and being open to compromise and negotiation. It also requires trust and respect for each other’s autonomy.

Independence

Independence is often valued in Western societies as a sign of strength and self-reliance. However, like codependence, it can become problematic if taken to an extreme. Independence involves the ability to make decisions and take actions on your own, without relying on others for validation or approval.

Examples of independent behavior

Examples of independent behavior include making decisions based on your own values and desires, pursuing personal goals, and taking responsibility for your own emotions and actions. Independence can be especially important in situations where someone’s safety or well-being is at risk, such as leaving an abusive relationship.

The positive impact of independence on relationships

The positive impact of independence on relationships is that it promotes self-growth and self-esteem. It also allows for more freedom and autonomy, which can be important in maintaining a healthy sense of identity.

How to recognize if you are independent

Recognizing if you are independent can also be challenging. Some signs of healthy independence include feeling comfortable with being alone, setting and achieving personal goals, and making decisions based on your own values and desires. However, it’s important to remember that no one is completely independent, and counting on others for support and guidance is a natural part of life.

How to develop independence

Developing independence involves building self-confidence and self-esteem. This can be done through self-reflection, setting and achieving personal goals, and seeking out new experiences and challenges. It also involves learning to rely on yourself for validation and approval, rather than seeking it from others.

Cultural Contexts: How does this translate? 

It’s important to note that the definitions and cultural significance of these 3 types can vary across different cultures. For example, in collectivist cultures, such as those found in many Asian countries, interdependence is highly valued. In contrast, individualistic cultures, such as those found in North America and Western Europe, tend to place a higher value on independence.

Understanding the cultural context of these concepts is important in developing healthy relationships. It can also help us to be more open-minded and accepting of different perspectives and ways of relating to others. Cultivating a balance of connection, care, self-care, supporting another and receiving support within different cultural contexts involves being aware of our own biases and assumptions, and being open to learning from others.

To sum it up

In conclusion, understanding the differences between the 3 types of closeness is crucial for building and maintaining healthy relationships. Codependent behavior can harm relationships, while interdependence can enhance them, and independence can create a healthy sense of self but overdoing it can lead to feelings of loneliness. 

Remember that developing a healthy balance is the key to healthy relationships. It is also important to acknowledge the influence of culture on our relationship dynamics and seek to cultivate a balance within different cultural contexts that works best for you.

By recognizing and working on these important concepts, you can cultivate healthier, more fulfilling relationships in all areas of your life. 

---

Want some help? Join our community

If you’d like proactive support, therapy tools and a deeper dive into how we create that balance, you’ll want to join the upcoming series of Secure Path workshops. These workshops are designed to develop healthy, thriving and secure relationships with both ourselves, covering:

• tackling unhealthy levels of dependency, independence and codependency
  
• explore the insecure and secure attachment styles
  
• learn communication skills for effective self-assertion
  
• unpack relationship trauma and unhealed wounds
  
• learn emotional regulation techniques to self-soothe relationship trauma triggers
  
• create a bespoke self-care system depending on where you are at
  

and much more!

Find out about launch dates or recording access on the Events & Workshops page.  

FAQ